Is It Time to Replace Your Filters? Here’s How to Tell

By PHS Education Team • Published May 7, 2025

Your water might look clean. It might even taste okay.
But if you haven’t changed your filters in a while, your well water system could be working overtime—and not doing its job the way it should.

Replacing filters is one of the most important (and easiest) parts of water treatment system maintenance. And yet, many homeowners forget about it… until something smells, tastes, or feels wrong.

In this article, we’ll show you how to tell when your filters need changing, why it matters, and how often to do it—especially here in Southwest Florida, where water conditions can be extra harsh.


Why Filters Matter in the First Place

Water filters are like the unsung heroes of your system.
They trap dirt, iron, chlorine, sulfur smells, bacteria, and even bad tastes before that water gets to your faucet.

If your filters are clogged or worn out, you’re basically drinking, cooking, and showering with untreated water.


Signs Your Filters Are Ready to Be Replaced

You don’t have to be a water expert to spot a tired filter. Here’s what to watch for:

1️⃣ Bad Smells or Tastes

If your water starts smelling like rotten eggs or tasting metallic, it could mean your carbon or sulfur filter is used up.

2️⃣ Rust or Stains in the Bathroom

Orange or black stains in sinks, toilets, or showers? That’s usually iron or manganese getting past an iron filter that needs changing.

3️⃣ Cloudy Water or Particles

Sediment filters trap sand, grit, and debris. When they’re full, it all slips right through—and into your glass.

4️⃣ Low Water Pressure

Clogged filters restrict flow, which can make your showers weak and your faucet pressure drop.

5️⃣ It’s Been Over 6 Months (Or You Can’t Remember)

If you’re scratching your head trying to remember the last time you changed your filters… it’s time.


Which Filters Are We Talking About?

Here’s a quick guide to common filter types and what they do:

Filter Type What It Does When to Replace
Sediment Filter Removes sand, dirt, and debris Every 6–12 months
Carbon Filter Removes chlorine, smells, and taste Every 6–9 months
Iron Filter Media Removes iron and sulfur Clean annually, replace every 3–5 years
RO Membrane Filters out contaminants like lead, fluoride, and bacteria Every 2–3 years
Pre/Post RO Filters Protect and polish water in RO systems Every 6–12 months

Note: Water in Fort Myers and Lehigh Acres can wear out filters faster due to higher levels of iron, hardness, and sulfur. So when in doubt, replace sooner than later.


The Risk of Ignoring Filter Maintenance

What happens when filters go too long?

  • Poor water quality (even if your system seems on)

  • Bacteria growth in dirty filters

  • System failure due to blockages or backflow

  • Increased wear and tear on pumps and valves

  • Health risks from drinking or bathing in unfiltered water

And worst of all? When your water system stops working, you’re the last to know—until the water turns orange or starts smelling awful.


Can You Replace Filters Yourself?

Yes, many filters are homeowner-friendly!

Just make sure to:

  • Shut off water before replacing

  • Wear gloves if you’re handling used filters

  • Sanitize housings if necessary

  • Keep a schedule (mark your calendar or use reminders)

But if you’re not sure how—or if your system has multiple stages—call in a pro who specializes in water conditioning Cape Coral or water treatment Lehigh Acres. They’ll do it fast, clean, and right.


Pro Tip: Bundle Filter Changes Into a Maintenance Plan

The easiest way to stay on top of filter changes? Sign up for a professional maintenance plan.
This way, you get:

  • Regular filter replacements

  • Full system checkups

  • Salt or citric acid delivery

  • Valve checks and system cleaning

  • Peace of mind that your water is safe year-round

It’s one of the best investments you can make for your home—and your health.


Final Thoughts: Don’t Wait for Trouble

Filters are small. But they do big work.
And when they go too long without attention, your whole system suffers.

Don’t wait for bad smells, rust stains, or gross tastes to remind you.
Put filter changes on your calendar, or let a local pro handle it with a smart service plan.

Because clean, safe, great-tasting water?
It starts with a fresh filter.

Table of Contents

Translate »